Expert Evidence. Omissions in its use and irregularities in its implementation: Study of a case

Ismael García Garduza

2024, Number 2

<< Back Next >>

Rev Mex Med Forense 2024; 9 (2)

Expert Evidence. Omissions in its use and irregularities in its implementation: Study of a case

García GI

Full text

How to cite this article

Language: Spanish
References: 10
Page: 48-69
PDF size: 598.00 Kb.

ABSTRACT

Introduction. The objective of this article is to demonstrate how expert evidence fulfills a significant function within a criminal process, since through it, it can be reconstructed and, in turn, prove or disprove a given fact, in order to get closer or reach it. to the truth, as long as it is used timely and meets the technical-scientific requirements in its execution. Through a real case, the consequences that result from the Public Prosecutor's Office not requesting expert opinions and the reconstruction of the event will be known to verify the veracity of the statements and understand the event; Likewise, the defense attorney did not use those resources to support his defense; Also, methodological and legal breaches committed by official experts when investigating and carrying out their procedures will be shown.
Conclusion. The irregularities in the investigation by the Public Prosecutor and the official experts, as well as the negligence of the defense lawyer, caused a person to be declared guilty, violating his Human Rights to the administration of justice and freedom.

REFERENCES

José E. Telich-Tarriba y otros. Lesiones nerviosas en extremidad pélvica y su manejo en uncentro de referencia en la Ciudad de México. Cir Cir. 2020;89(2):200-205.
Hernando Rafael Cruz. Trasplante de epiplón para el nervio ciático lesionado. Acta Med Per27(1) 2010: 43-44.
Tobón-Marulanda F, Vallejo-Maya J, Toro-Cortés LM. Lesión del nervio ciático: aproximaciónmédico legal. Rev CES Med 2011; 25(1):65-78.
Arilla, Fernando, El Procedimiento Penal en México, 14ª ed., Editorial Kratos. México1992. p.144.
Tesis. Registro digital: 177849. Instancia: Tribunales Colegiados de Circuito. Novena Época.Materias(s): Penal. Tesis: I.7o.P.66 P. Fuente: Semanario Judicial de la Federación y su Gaceta.Tomo XXII, Julio de 2005, página 1507. Tipo: Aislada.
Carrancá y Trujillo R., Código Penal Anotado, 20ª ed., Editorial Porrúa, México, 1997, p. 752.
García Garduza Ismael. Procedimiento Pericial Médico Normas que lo Rigen y Los DerechosHumanos. 5ª. Ed. Editorial Porrúa. México, 2017.
Mtro. José Luis Varela Ruiz. Análisis químico comparativo de disparos de arma de fuego decartuchos de 9mm de diferentes marcas en prendas. Visión Criminológica-criminalística. 2018:82-85.
Peña José Antonio. Fenómenos cadavéricos y el tanatocronodiagnóstico. Gac. Int. Cienc.Forense. 2019: Nº 31: 10-37.
Tesis. Registro digital: 2021099. Instancia: Primera Sala. Décima Época. Materias(s):Constitucional, Penal. Tesis: 1a. C/2019 (10a.). Fuente: Gaceta del Semanario Judicial de laFederación. Libro 72, Noviembre de 2019, Tomo I, página 366. Tipo: Aislada.