Language: Spanish
References: 74
Page: 125-138
PDF size: 174.97 Kb.
ABSTRACT
Introduction
This research offers a comprehensive analysis of the distinctive status of Alcohol in two types of young consumers (alcohol and alcohol/cannabis), which is internalised by the consumers themselves, creating a distortion in their risk perceptions inherent to experimentation.
In this sense, the focus of this study is on the change experienced in the attitude sphere in a threefold dimension: cognitive factors (beliefs, expectations, perceptions, etc.), affective factors (identification with the user, liking or disliking, etc.), and behavioural factors (inclination to accept the habit); as well as risk perception and the conscience of the physical and/or psychosocial damage derived from alcohol experimentation and the motivations that lead to its consumption in a sample of adolescents from four High Schools in the Principality of Asturias (Spain).
We link such attitude profiles to the social representation of recreational drugs associated with socio-cognitive restructurating processes promoted by the corresponding user mentalities.
In addition, there is evidence of the influence of the sociocultural context on the distinctive status of the psychoactive substances analysed, in this case alcohol and those derived from cannabis.
Contrary to the high permissiveness towards alcohol, other psychoactive substances, such as cannabis products, are socially demonised, as they have been considered a gateway for the use of other drugs coming from a tradition far from the western one. However, there appear to be more permissive consciences lately.
In relation to young people, attitudes of guilt are being made more flexible, a tendency that can be extended to the distortion of risk perception in alcohol consumption among the users of cannabis products themselves. Strictly, we should consider the distinctive perceptions of the risks associated with experimentation and the attitude patterns that identify them. We must also consider cannabis products and whether or not they are being compared to alcohol as a social drug, or if, on the contrary, the rejection conscience of such practices is being reinforced.
Materials and method
A distinctive and descriptive analysis of users of alcohol and cannabis products with respect to non-users is presented. This analysis encompasses the attitude sphere, risk perception and the knowledge of the negative consequences derived from the use of alcohol and other experimentation with psychoactive substances in a sample of 273 adolescents, chosen from four High Schools in the Principality of Asturias (Spain) by means of an intentional sampling.
They have different academic levels and are within the ages of 14 to 18, the average age being 16.5. 140 of them are girls (51.3% of the sample) and 133 boys (48.7% remaining).
The main variables studied are those related to attitudes towards adolescents’ use of alcohol alone and those who habitually use it with cannabis products. The main study variables are represented by the attitude sphere, risk perception, the problematic of alcohol consumption, and the knowledge of the negative consequences derived from alcohol consumption and from other experimentations with cannabis and other psychoactive substances.
A questionnaire, created
ad hoc, has been provided by the researchers, which, under the label of
Scale of attitudes and habits of alcohol consumption, includes an analysis of different related elements in the aetiological proposal. The value of Alpha in 273 valid cases and 142 items is .9171.
With regard to the research procedure, an anonymous presentation of the Scale to the aforementioned group of students over a two-week time period has been prepared. For the statistical treatment of the data, a statistics package SPSS, version 14.0 has been used.
Results
According to the results obtained, it is confirmed that adolescent alcohol consumers, on one hand, and those who consume alcohol and cannabis products, on the other, show attitudes of great permissiveness towards consumption, distorted beliefs and expectations, socio-affective alienation and scarce sensitising with respect to those affected by the problematic of it, and a favourable disposition to consumption and even an alcoholic habituation.
Firstly, a comparative analysis of response percentages has been done, before indicators through which different aspects of the cognitive, affective and behavioural dimensions of the attitude towards alcohol consumption are evaluated, along with the distortion of risk perception and basic information about the consequences derived from consumption experiences, in either adolescents who are users of alcohol, or those who, apart from alcohol, are habitual users of cannabis products.
From the descriptive analysis some conclusions can be drawn such as:
• Obvious permissive disposition towards the process of alcoholic habituation in adolescent users of alcohol, mainly extensible to users of both alcohol and cannabis products.
• From the evaluation of the cognitive dimension of the attitudes, explicit disposition is confirmed, in the sense of displaying a distortion of these attitudes. This can be attributed to, as it has been pointed out in the theoretical exposition, the possible action of the user mentality.
• In the evaluation of attitude aspects, a dominant tendency to display a scarce identification and sensitising disposition with respect to those who give up drinking or are abstemious and even to openly show rejection to congratulating somebody that has given up drinking.
• Lastly, the finding of coincidences between adolescent alcohol users and those who also use cannabis products in the determination of the main motivations that drive their alcohol consumption.
The tendency of a more permissive attitude towards alcohol consumption in adolescents is confirmed along with a distorted perception of the risks derived from questions related to organic damage associated with experimentation. In the evaluation of the alcoholism problematic in our society, we also have found the confirmation of a mentality associated with experimentation that leads to a distortion of the damages derived from experimentation.
Therefore, with respect to the distinctive analysis of the main motivations that drive alcohol consumption, a tendency of evasion of routine is confirmed. Peer pressure by consumer friends, disposition to lose one’s inhibitions, meeting people, and experiencing euphoria are the main reasons that drive experimentation in adolescents who consume alcohol and, also, in those users of both alcohol and cannabis products.
A tendency to recognise the scarce negative consequences suffered is derived from the analysis of the degree of perceived problems stemming from experimentation with different psychoactive substances, as well as the risk perception and negative consequences derived from their experiences of alcohol consumption and from the main explicit reasons for not drinking.
According to an analysis procedure similar to the aforementioned, the importance of the differences found between consumers and nonconsumers either of alcohol or both alcohol and cannabis products could be determined, confirming recognition of worse consequences perceived on physical and psychosocial health derived from experimentation, even though it cannot benefit a real consciousness, as has been confirmed through the previous attitude analysis.
Certainly, from the distinctive analysis of risk perception factors and the reasons given for not drinking, it has been confirmed that adolescents experimenting with psychoactive substances, alcohol and cannabis products in this case, display, as a group, a smaller perception of the risks associated with experimentation, as compared to the greater knowledge of potential alcoholic damage in non-users. Thus, being a question that, in the case of consumers, is indicative of lesser sensitising before the problem and a distorted perception of its possible negative consequences on behalf of the user mentality.
Conclusion and discussion
The importance of the modulating action in the perception of adolescents with the so-called user mentalities is pointed out, associated with the permissive social representation of alcohol conditioned in turn by the socio-cultural context and experimentation regulations.
In this study of the attitude sphere analysis under the threefold dimension model specified (cognitive, affective and behavioural) a preliminary conclusion has to be drawn according to the agreement shown by adolescent alcohol users on one hand, and both alcohol and cannabis product users on the other hand, in order to display more permissive attitudes towards consumption, beliefs, false expectations, socio-affective detachment and scarce sensitising with respect to those affected by the problematic and a favourable disposition to consumption, and even alcoholic habituation.
On the contrary, adolescent non-users show the opposite attitudes towards alcohol consumption such as higher sensitising, clearer beliefs, more resistant disposition against experimentation, and a more accurate evaluation of the reality of the effects and consequences of consumption that influence how a substance, such as alcohol, is perceived with its long tradition in the Mediterranean culture that affects the social representations built around the substance and the institutional treatment of it.
REFERENCES
Casa MJ, O’Ferral C, Vaca FJ. Evolución del perfil del enfermo alcohólico durante los últimos veinte años. Rev Esp Drogodependencias 2001;26(2):127-134.
Ordoñana JR. Los jóvenes y el consumo de alcohol. ¿Qué les estamos diciendo? Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2000;14(4):413-415.
Pascual F. Percepción del alcohol entre los jóvenes. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2002;14(supl.1):123-132.
Moral MV, Ovejero A. Actitudes ante el consumo de sustancias psicoactivas y mentalidades del usuario en adolescentes. Entemu. UNED Centro Asociado de Asturias 2003;XV:151-175.
Moral MV, Ovejero A. Análisis diferencial por niveles de edad de las actitudes hacia el consumo de sustancias psicoactivas en adolescentes españoles. Interam J Psychol 2005;39(3):325-338.
Arana X, Marquez I, Vega A. Drogas. Cambios sociales y legales ante el tercer milenio. Madrid: Dykinson; 2000.
Rodríguez E, Megías E. Una aproximación al cambio de las representaciones sociales sobre drogas en España. Trastor Adict 2000;3:193-198.
Megías E (dir.). Los valores de la sociedad española y su relación con las drogas. Colección Estudios Sociales, 2. Barcelona: Fundación la Caixa; 2000.
Megías E, Comas D, Navarro J, Elzo, J, Romani O. Percepción social de los problemas de drogas en España. Madrid: FAD; 2000.
Sánchez-Carbonell X. Contexto cultural y consecuencias legales del consumo de drogas. Trastor Adict 2004;6(1):1-4.
Medina-Mora ME, Cravioto P, Villatoro J, Fleiz C, Galván-Castillo F et al. Consumo de drogas entre adolescentes: resultados de la Encuesta Nacional de Adicciones. Salud Pública Méx 2003;45(Supl.1):516-525.
Arellanez-Hernández JL, Díaz-Negrete DB, Wagner-Echegaray F, Pérez- Islas V. Factores psicosociales asociados con el abuso y la dependencia de drogas entre adolescentes: análisis bivariados de un estudio de casos y controles. Salud Mental 2003;27(3):54-64.
Berenzon S, Medina-Mora ME, Carreño S, Juárez F, Villatoro J et al. Las tendencias del consumo de sustancias psicoactivas entre los estudiantes de enseñanza media y media superior del Distrito Federal, 1993. Salud Mental 1996;19(1):1-5.
Caballero R, Madrigal E, Hidalgo A, Villaseñor A. El consumo de tabaco, alcohol, y drogas ilegales, en los adolescentes de diferentes estratos socioeconómicos de Guadalajara. Salud Mental 1999;22(4):1-8.
Fleiz C, Borges G, Rojas E, Benjet C, Medina-Mora ME. Uso de alcohol, tabaco y drogas en población mexicana, un estudio de cohortes. Salud Mental 2007;30(5):63-73.
Galván J, Ortiz A, Soriano A, Casanova L. Tendencias del uso de drogas en la Ciudad de México (1986-2003). Sistema de reporte de información sobre drogas. Salud Mental 2005;28(3):51-59.
Nuño-Gutiérrez BL, Alvarez-Nemegyei J, Madrigal-De León E, Rasmussen- Cruz B. Prevalencia y factores asociados al consumo de tabaco en adolescentes de una preparatoria de Guadalajara, Jalisco, México. Salud Mental 2005;28(5):64-70.
Mora-Ríos J, Natera G, Juárez F. Expectativas relacionadas con el alcohol en la predicción del abuso en el consumo en jóvenes. Salud Mental 2005;28(2):82-90.
Rojas E, Medina-Mora ME, Juárez F, Carreño S, Villatoro J et al. El consumo de bebidas alcohólicas y variables asociadas entre los estudiantes de México. Salud Mental 1995;18(3):22-27.
Solís L, Cordero M, Cordero R, Martínez M. Caracterización del nivel de dependencia al alcohol entre habitantes de la Ciudad de México. Salud Mental 2007;30(6):62-68.
Allport G. Attitudes. En: Murchison C (ed.). Handbook of social psychology. New York: Clark University Press; 1935.
Wickler AW. Attitudes versus actions: the relationship of verbal and overt behavioral responses to attitude objects. En: Thomas K (ed.). Attitudes and behavior. New York: Routledge and Regan Paul, Penguin; 1969.
Festinger L. Teoría de la disonancia cognoscitiva. Madrid: Instituto de la Opinión Pública; 1975.
Heider F. The psychology of interpersonal relations. New York: Wiley; 1958.
Newcomb T. An approach to the study of communicative acts. Psychological Review 1953;60:393-404.
Osgood C, Tannebaum P. The principle of congruity in the prediction of attitude changes. Psychological Review 1955;62:42-55.
Rosenberg MJ, Abelson R. An analysis of cognitive balancing. En: Abelson R (ed.). Theories of cognitive consistency: a sourcebook. Chicago: Rand McNally; 1960.
Haddock G, Zanna M. Cognition, affect and the prediction of social attitude. En: Stroke S, Hewston M (eds.). European review of social psychology. Vol 10. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1999.
Moscovici S. On social representations. En: Forgas JP (ed.). Social cognition. London: Academic Press; 1981.
Moscovici S. The coming era of social representations. En: Codol JP, Leyens JP (eds.). Cognitive approaches to social behavior. La Haya: Nijhoff; 1982.
Moscovici S. The phenomenon of social representations. En: Farr RM, Moscovici S (eds.). Social representations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1984.
Banchs M. Aproximaciones procesuales y estructurales al estudio de las representaciones sociales. Papers Social Representations 1999;8:1-15.
Jodelet D. La representación social: fenómenos, conceptos y teoría. En: Moscovici S (ed.). Psicología social. Vol. 2. Barcelona: Paidós; 1986.
Fundación de Ayuda contra la Drogadicción (FAD). La percepción de los problemas de drogas en España 2004. Madrid: Fundación de Ayuda Contra la Drogadicción; 2005.
Aguilera R. Generación botellón. Madrid: Obreron; 2002.
Calafat A, Fernández C, Becoña E, Gil E, Juan M et al. Consumo y consumidores de cannabis en la vida recreativa. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2000;12(2):197-230.
Moral MV. Jóvenes, sustancias psicoactivas e identidad. Propuesta de prevención e intervención psicosocial y comunitaria. Tesis Doctoral. Oviedo: Universidad de Oviedo; 2002.
Moral MV. Personalidad, resiliencia y otros factores psicosociales asociados al consumo de sustancias psicoactivas en la adolescencia: propuesta etiológica. Monografía personalidad y consumo de drogas. Rev Esp Drogodependencias 2007;32(3):250-291.
Kandel DB. Stages in adolescent involvement in drug use. Science 1975;190:912-914.
Kandel DB. Longitudinal research on drug use. Empirical findings and methological issues. Washington, DC: Wiley; 1978.
Plan Nacional sobre Drogas. Encuesta sobre drogas a la población escolar 2003. Madrid: Delegación del Gobierno para el Plan Nacional sobre Drogas; 2004.
Plan Nacional sobre Drogas. Encuesta sobre drogas a la población escolar 2004. Madrid: Delegación del Gobierno para el Plan Nacional sobre Drogas; 2005.
Plan Nacional sobre Drogas. Informe sobre el consumo de alcohol en España. Madrid: Delegación del Gobierno para el Plan Nacional sobre Drogas; 2007.
Barturen F. Farmacología e interés terapéutico del cannabis y sus derivados. En: Meana JJ, Pantoja L (eds.). Derivados del cannabis: ¿drogas o medicamentos? Avances en farmacología de drogodependencias. Bilbao: Universidad de Deusto; 1998.
Espada JP, Méndez X, Griffin K, Botvin GJ. Adolescencia: consumo de alcohol y otras drogas. Pap Psicól 2003;84:9-17.
Bobes J, Bascarán MT, González MP, Saiz PA. Epidemiología del uso/abuso del cannabis. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2000;12(Supl. 2):31-40.
Laespada MT. Consumo de drogas entre escolares donostiarras: un estudio longitudinal durante 21 años. Rev Esp Drogodependencias 2003;28(1-2):24-47.
Barrio G, Bravo MJ, De la Fuente L. Consumo de drogas ilegales en España: hacia una diversificación de los patrones de consumo y los problemas asociados. Enf Emerg 2000;2:2-16.
Fernández J, Alvarez E, Secades R, Jiménez JM, Cañada A et al. Consumo de drogas de síntesis en estudiantes de secundaria del principado de Asturias (España). Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2003;15(1):31-37.
García-Portilla MP, Saiz P, Paredes B, Martínez S, Bobes J. Personalidad y uso-abuso de éxtasis (MDMA). Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2003;15(Supl. 2):199-205.
Saiz PA, García-Portilla MP, Paredes B, Bobes J. Evolución histórica del uso y abuso de MMDA. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2003;15(Supl. 2):35-49.
Monrás M. Cambios en la edad de inicio del tratamiento de la dependencia alcohólica. ¿Debemos cambiar la oferta asistencial? Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2001;13(2):139-146.
Robles G. La política española sobre drogodependencias: situación actual y perspectivas futuras. Trastor Adict 2003;5(3):199-212.
Balcells M. Toxicología del cannabis. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2000;12(Supl.2):169-174.
Vázquez F, Becoña E. Factores de riesgo y escalada cannabinoide. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2000;12(Supl. 2):175-184.
Ellickson PL, Tucker JS, Klein DJ, McGuigan KA. Factores prospectivos de riesgo para problemas relacionados con el alcohol en la etapa final de la adolescencia. J Stud Alcohol 2001;62(4):773-782.
Guo J, Hawkins JD, Hill KG, Abbot RD. Predictores en la infancia y adolescencia del alcohol en las primeras etapas de la edad adulta. J Stud Alcohol 2001;62(6):754-762.
Sirvent C, Moral MV, Rodríguez FJ. Jóvenes & alcohol. conjunto didáctico–audiovisual para educadores, psicólogos y colectivos mediadores. Valencia: Nau Llibres; 2007.
Moral MV, Rodríguez FJ, Sirvent C. Motivadores de consumo de alcohol en adolescentes: Análisis de las diferencias intergénero y propuesta de un continuum etiológico. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2005;17(2):105-120.
Macià D, Méndez FX, Olivares J. Intervención psicológica. Programas aplicados de tratamiento. Madrid: Pirámide; 1993.
Macià D. Cuestionario de actitudes acerca del alcohol y cuestionario de información. Método conductual de prevención de drogodependencias. Valencia: Promolibro; 1986.
Arnau M. Cambios en la edad de inicio del tratamiento de la dependencia alcohólica. ¿Debemos cambiar la oferta asistencial? Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2001;13(2):139-146.
Calafat A, Juan M, Becoña E, Castillo A, Fernández C et al. El consumo de alcohol en la lógica del botellón. Adicciones. Rev Socidrogalcohol 2005;17(3):193-202.
Flores D, González J, Robledo T, Rubio J, Espiga I et al. Plan europeo de actuación sobre alcohol 2000-2005. Organización Mundial de la Salud Europea. Dirección General de Salud Pública y Consumo. Madrid: Subsecretaría de Sanidad y Consumo. Ministerio de Sanidad y Consumo; 2000.
Robledo T. Consumo juvenil de alcohol: ¿Existe una perspectiva salubrista a nivel europeo? Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2003; 15(supl.1):74.
Amengual M. Enfoques preventivos del uso y abuso de cannabis y problemas asociados. Adicciones Rev Socidrogalcohol 2000;12(2):275-280.
Bach i Bach L. La falta de conciencia del daño alcohólico, firme impedimento para la prevención primaria y secundaria del alcoholismo. Rev Esp Drogodependencias 2000;25(2):114-117.
Castellana M, Lladó M. Adolescencia y juventud: Prevención y percepción del riesgo al consumo. Rev Esp Drogodependencias 1999;24:118-130.
Pons J, Berjano E. El consumo abusivo de alcohol en la adolescencia. Madrid: Plan Nacional Sobre Drogas; 1999.
Sussman S, Ames SL. The social psychology of drug abuse. Ballmoor: Open University Press; 2001.
Nuño-Gutiérrez BL, Alvarez-Nemegyei J, González-Forteza C, Madeigal- De León E. La adicción ¿vicio o enfermedad? Imágenes y uso de servicios de salud en adolescentes usuarios y sus padres. Salud Mental 2006;29(4):47-54.
Medina-Mora ME, Nátera G, Borges G, Cravioto P, Fleiz C et al. Del siglo XX al tercer milenio. Las adicciones y la salud pública: drogas, alcohol y sociedad. Salud Mental 2001;24(4):3-19.
Gual A. Los problemas son globales, las políticas locales. Adicciones. Rev Socidrogalcohol 2006;18(3):237-238.
Arbex C. Catálogo de programas de ocio saludable. Madrid: ADES; 2000.