Angulo-Bernal SE, Leyva-González FA, Viniegra-Velázquez L

Language: Spanish
References: 21
Page: 168-179
PDF size: 94.38 Kb.

ABSTRACT

Objective. To investigate the professors of technical courses of the area of health, the effects of a promotional educative strategy of the participation in the development of a position prior to the education and of the aptitude for the critical theoretical text reading and information of educative research. Material and methods. A longitudinal study took place, of intervention. In order to measure the degree of development of a position before the education, it was applied to the instrument Concepts and ideas about education. It consists of 72 statements, organized in duple that expresses two different approaches from education: participative and passive. For the inquiry of the degree of development of critical reading two instruments were applied: 1) Theoretical text reading of education and, 2) Reading information of educative research, constituted both by 120 ítemes. The validity and trustworthiness of the three instruments were valued by experts with experience in teaching and educative research. The strategy was implemented through activities in seminary form, which were done twice a week, with a duration of five hours per session, for nine months; within the activities outside the classroom, the student completed reading of a theoretical text and/or report of educative research and the resolution of a reading guide (task). During the activities in a propitious classroom, discussion atmosphere and promoting at any moment the participation of the students; a space for the reflective recovery of their own experience was opened, for the analysis and interchange of ideas and for the critic and self-criticism of the main educative practices. The professor intervened when individual participation diminished; he also channeled the discussion, indicating to the enlightening observations and strong arguments of the students. The three instruments were applied to the group of professors of aprentechnical courses (n = 10); the initial measurement was applied before initiating the educative strategy and the final measurement at the end of the same plan. The qualification of the instruments and the capture of information were made by a blind technical worker. Results. Subsequent to the educative strategy we observed a statistically significant advance in position –inferred through its main indicator: critical theoretical text consequence– and reading. The advances shown in critical reading for information of educative research were below the critical theoretical text reading. Conclusions. The development of position before the education and the aptitudes for critical reading of theoretical texts and information of educative research, in professors of technical courses of the area of health, it is possible, if educative atmospheres are created that lead to the participation –halfway through by the critic–.

REFERENCES

1. Gómez-Sánchez E, Monterrosas R. Seguimiento de egresados de los cursos para la formación del personal técnico a nivel nacional del Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social, presentado en el Seminario Interinstitucional de Investigación Educativa en Ciencias de la Salud, México, 1995.

2. Viniegra VL. Replanteamiento de la función de la escuela. En: Educación y Crítica. El proceso de elaboración del conocimiento. México: Paidós Educador; 2002, p. 105-54.

3. Piaget J. Psicología y Epistemología. Buenos Aires: Emecé Editores; 1998, p. 7-26 y 47-62.

4. Piaget J. Los nuevos métodos educativos y sus bases psicológicas. En: Psicología y Pedagogía. México: Editorial Planeta Mexicana; 1991, p. 157-207.

5. Freire P. El acto de estudiar. Alfabetización de adultos: visión crítica y visión ingenua. El proceso de alfabetización política. Llamada a la concienciación y a la desescolarización. En: La naturaleza política de la educación. España: Paidós; 1990, p. 29-62 y 171-95.

6. Viniegra VL. La perspectiva educativa. En: Hacia otra concepción del currículo. Un camino alternativo para la formación de investigadores. Edición México IMSS, Unidad de Investigación Educativa; 1999, p. 13-70.

7. Viniegra VL. El camino de la crítica y la educación. Rev Invest Clín 1996; 48: 139-58.

8. Coll SC. Un marco psicológico para el currículo escolar. En: Aprendizaje escolar y construcción del conocimiento. México: Paidós; 2000, p. 153-73.

9. Smith RL. A factor –analytic study of critical reading/thinking, influence ability and related factors. Eric; 1971.

10. Domhnall MAD, McCrum E, Brown C. Randomized controlled trial of the Reader method of critical appraisal in general practice. BMJ 1998; 316: 1134-7.

11. Stern DT, et al. Evaluating medical resident’s literature appraisal skills. Academic Medicine 1995; 70(2): 152-4.

12. Leyva GF, Viniegra VL. Lectura crítica en médicos residentes de especialidades troncales. Rev Invest Clín 1999; 51: 31-8.

13. Aguilar ME, Viniegra VL. Una mirada del proceso educativo. La postura del profesor ante la educación y su práctica. En: La Investigación en la educación. Papel de la teoría y de la observación. México: IMSS; 2000, p. 46-66.

14. Aguilar ME, Viniegra VL. El papel cambiante del profesor. Un estudio en grupos de estudiantes de la licenciatura en pedagogía. En: La investigación en la educación: papel de la teoría y de la observación, México: IMSS; 2000, p. 157-99.

15. Garza P, Rico G, Insfrán M. Evaluación de la postura del docente ante la educación a través de dos miradas. Rev Enferm IMSS 2003; 11: 13-8.

16. Espinosa AP, Viniegra VL. Efecto de una estrategia educativa sobre la lectura crítica en estudiantes de medicina. Rev Invest Clín 1994; 46: 447-56.

17. Cobos AH, Espinosa AP, Viniegra VL. Comparación de dos estrategias educativas en la lectura crítica de médicos residentes. Rev Invest Clin 1996; 48: 43-6.

18. Sabido SM, Viniegra VL, Espinosa AP, Nava CHM. Evaluación de una estrategia educativa para desarrollar la lectura crítica en médicos del primer nivel de atención. Rev Med IMSS 1997; 35 (1): 49-53.

19. Insfrán SMD, Cobos AH. Lectura crítica de investigación clínica por médicos internos de pregrado. Rev Med IMSS 2003; 41: 281-7.

20. Bisquerra R. Métodos de muestreo. En: Métodos de Investigación Educativa. Barcelona: Ceac; 1988, p. 81-5.

21. Viniegra VL. El desafió de la educación en el IMSS: Cómo constituirse en la avanzada de la superación institucional. Rev Med IMSS 2005; 43 (4): 305-31.